Take the time to read this, it will help -
GUIDELINES FOR ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW DECISIONS -
A loss of 1% of our property value is worth $1,500,000 (one and a half million dollars)
Protecting resident's property values is the primary purpose of our covenants and the Architectural Review Board. This is done by maintaining a sense of aesthetics that is consistent with our covenants and reflects the practices of similarly valued neighborhoods.
Basically the guidelines can be thought of as the golden rule "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you".
1) If the requested change to an owner’s property were to be instituted throughout the subdivision - would the property values of Ashborough likely go up or down. If the answer is down, then the request would likely be denied. We don't feel we have the right to grant changes for individual homeowners when the proposed change would have a negative effect on Ashborough if everyone were allowed to do the same thing. That would be favoritism.
Example 1: a homeowner wants to cover his front yard with gravel to cut down on yard care. If all Ashborough residents were to gravel their yards, property values would surely suffer. We would have to deny permission.
Example 2: a homeowner wants to remove a healthy grand tree causing no damage and even has Dorchester county approval. An important part of the value of Ashborough is the large lots with mature trees. If one person can cut down healthy trees then all could. We would strive for a compromise - if none could be reached we would have to deny permission.
2) If the requested change would negatively affect the property values or ‘livability’ of an immediate neighbor, we would likely deny. We will make these decisions without consulting with the immediate neighbors. We feel it's important to avoid creating an atmosphere of 'neighbor versus neighbor'.
Example: a request is made for a storage shed that, by itself, does not reduce the property values of the neighborhood. However, if the requested location of the shed is out of the normal line of sight of the owner (they don't want to have to look at it) but it is an eyesore to the next door neighbor, the site location would not be approved.